- When we have an “umbrella emotion” (as we therapists call it) we have one dominant emotional reaction (lets say anger), that preoccupies us, but under the umbrella of anger may exist other emotions (like shame, guilt, fear – etc) that need to be addressed and resolved for us to feel at peace with a situation.
- The reason it’s called an umbrella emotion is because the emotion we are most intensely in touch with is “hiding” other emotions under it, often ones we have difficulty accessing and feeling our way through – much in the same way we hide under an umbrella to shield ourselves from the rain.
- When this emotional nesting happens we are not able to be in touch (consciously) with all that we are feeling, and as such we are less able to work through it. We can get trapped in our emotional experiences for extended periods of time, or we can’t make sense of them, or perhaps we avoid thinking about them because they feel like “too much”.
- If you’re feeling “stuck” around releasing an emotion or situation, a helpful coping strategy is to go on an investigative mission within yourself to see what other emotions you may be feeling in addition to the dominant one you notice most. We usually don’t know what’s hiding under our umbrella until we go searching for it.
- To do this scan well, we first need to have developed a personal lexicon of our emotions. This means knowing how each emotion feels to us when it’s present within our bodies, the types of events that often trigger each emotion, and the kinds of thoughts that often accompany it.
- At a time when you’re feeling relatively even, take a moment to identify how Anger, Disgust, Envy, Fear, Happiness, Jealousy, Love, Sadness, Shame, and Guilt present themselves in you. Spend 30-60 seconds working to churn up each emotion in yourself and notice what you feel in your body and the kinds of thoughts (or memories) that arise.
- You’ll likely find as you do an internal inventory that some emotions are easy for you to “map”, and others feel much more distant. It’s likely those “easy” ones are – at times – serving as umbrella emotions to those feelings that are harder to access (and may be hiding).
- Once you’ve built your lexicon, you’re ready to use the coping skill at a time when you feel stuck. First, work to disengage (as much as you can) from the dominant emotion (you may need to ground or distract to do this). Then scan internally for evidence (AKA the thoughts and sensations you notice) that other emotions may be present within you.
- When we’ve found our umbrella emotion and whatever’s under it, it can be a huge relief (i.e. I had no idea I was feeling so guilty because I was so preoccupied with my anger, but now that I’ve found my guilt I feel like I can let go of the situation much more easily). It’s not uncommon to have an intense release when we find what’s been hiding.
- The more we can be in touch with our emotions, the more we can learn from them, regulate them, and be in control of our behavior when we feel them. More in today’s post and comments.
It’s not uncommon for our emotions to cluster and hide within one another, making them difficult to identify, sort through, process, and manage. Today’s skill is a form of emotion regulation, managing our emotions through identifying them. It helps to hold awareness that sometimes emotions hide, and so we have to search for and identify them before we are truly able to regulate them.
Why would our emotions hide? Our ability to feel and manage our emotions is hugely informed by prior experiences. Emotions that were welcomed when we developed will be easier for us to access, tolerate, and regulate. Emotions that were not welcome may get twisted and we may have to work to learn how to feel them, so they don’t come out exclusively on overdrive or jumbled up with other feelings.
That doesn’t sound like you? Sometimes we have beliefs about our feelings (fear is weakness, anger is destructive, etc). If we hold beliefs that some emotions are superior to others, we’ll have an easier time accessing those preferred emotions, and a harder time accessing those we’ve evaluated as problematic. Perhaps anger is easy for you to access because it helps you feel strong, protected, and tough – but guilt is less easy to access because it makes you feel vulnerable and weak. Getting in touch with all of these beliefs will help you build your personal internal lexicon, and help you better recognize and cope with your emotions.
Our emotions are most likely to get us into trouble when we aren’t fully in touch with them in our day to day life because they’re at risk of building up and exploding out of us, or we’re at risk of impulsively (and at times dangerously) responding to them.
IMPORTANT: When you are building your lexicon and getting in touch with different emotions you may get deeply overwhelmed or triggered if you tap into an emotion you have a highly negative relationship (or history) with. If this happens, you’ll likely need to self-soothe, ground, and distract to get back into your window of tolerance. Links to those skills are in the comments below, and if you’re concerned this will happen to you, wait to do this exercise with a trained professional (therapist /psychiatrist).
Comments:
- Safety first: some folks (Especially folks who have a trauma history) may get overwhelmed (or leave their window of tolerance) working to build their lexicon. If you are concerned this might be you, then START with working on learning how to ground, distract, soothe yourself, and identify when you’re out of your window of tolerance. Please know, if this is you, you are demonstrating a sign that you may need professional help tolerating the process of getting in touch with your feelings, which is essential for your well-being and mental health.
- The 10 emotions I listed are not the only ten emotions we are able to feel, however, they cover a lot of the bases. Feel free to add additional emotions to the list for your personal lexicon.
- This skill is an extension of skills taught in Marsha Linehan’s Dialectical Behavior Therapy Emotion Regulation Module in her DBT curriculum. Within her skills training workbook there is a lot of information about each of these emotions and how they often present.
- A lot of folks have a hard time telling envy and jealousy apart. A client actually gave me this incredibly simple framework that I will share with you all: Envy is related to something we don’t have but we want to have, Jealousy is related to having something we are concerned with losing.
- A lot of folks have a hard time with the difference between guilt and shame. Shame is a feeling we feel that’s a reflection of our core sense of our self (I am bad). It may or may not be related to an event, but it’s a sense of our character. Guilt is a feeling that’s arises as a reflection of our belief that we did something wrong (but not that we holistically are bad).
- I state in the post ” Emotions that were welcomed when we developed will be easier for us to access, tolerate, and regulate.” Please note that emotions can be “unwelcome” by others or by ourselves (For example: I’m afraid of my anger so I don’t want to feel it, but my parents didn’t have an issue with it – or – whenever I got angry I got in trouble so I learned it’s best not to feel or express it etc).
- Not buying into the idea that feeling our emotions is useful? I have a post for you to help you accept the need for your emotions.
- If you are saying to yourself (like many of my clients have previously said to me) “well I don’t ever feel that emotion”, then I am telling you (kindly) that you are cut off from it, because we all experience all of these emotions, it’s just a matter of how in touch we are with the fact that we’re feeling them. This doesn’t mean we all feel all of these all the time, or we should feel them in equal amounts, it just means that we all have the ability to feel them and do feel them when the situation calls for it. What I am suspect of is when someone says, “that doesn’t apply to me, I don’t feel _____”, I am not suspect of, “I rarely feel it, but yeah, I can map it in my body and get that I’m vulnerable to feeling it, even if do only rarely”. For example, we may not often feel envy which is different from “that doesn’t apply to me”.
- Are you having trouble staying present in yourself for the scan of your body and thoughts? If so, you may need to work on building up your capacity to tolerate being mindful with yourself. I have a whole series of posts that can help. Start with this post, on foundational meditation and then move on to this post which will help you build your tolerance for directly observing your internal world Not sure you buy into the idea of meditation? Start here.
- Struggle with beliefs around anger being “bad” or inherently problematic? I have a whole post on why we need it.
- See my post on the basics of emotions (like what they are, and how they show up in us) if you’re feeling confused about emotions in general. This will be especially helpful for anyone struggling to develop their personal lexicon. I have an additional post on how to understand the process of feeling and releasing an emotion. I also have a post about how emotions that we struggle to tolerate experiencing can impact us.
- Sometimes emotions under our umbrella are “secondary” emotions, or emotions we’ve had in response to an initial emotion. For more on what this is and how it works see my post from 10/3/21, first photo “Our emotions, when they are heightened, can feel like a freight train, plowing through and interrupting everything in their tracks”.
- There is an excellent book, for children, that helps them build their emotional lexicon from the very start. Color Monster comes as a popup and as a board book.
- If you’re wanting more for yourself (or for kids) about understand the function of emotions and how they work, Disney / Pixar’s “Inside Out” is a phenomenal resource.